Skip to main content

Emergency Medicine Training

← Back to blog

Pericardial Window: Indications, Approaches and How It Compares With Pericardiocentesis

Jason Hine 14 min read

Quick Answer

A pericardial window is a surgical procedure that removes a piece of the pericardium so a pericardial effusion can drain and is less likely to come back. Surgeons create it through a small incision below the xiphoid, a small left thoracotomy or thoracoscopically. It is one kind of surgical drainage, and the two terms aren’t interchangeable: tamponade from trauma, aortic dissection or cardiac rupture may need an operation that repairs the bleeding source, which a window doesn’t do. The drainage approach depends on the cause of tamponade, the patient’s condition, and available expertise.

What Is a Pericardial Window?

A pericardial window is an opening cut into the pericardium so that fluid has somewhere to go other than around the heart. The 2025 ESC guidelines on myocarditis and pericarditis describe the usual version as a pleuro-pericardial window, made between the lateral or left posterior pericardium and the left pleura, by a small thoracotomy or endoscopically. In selected cases, the window opens into the peritoneal cavity instead.

The operation also gives tissue. The same guideline notes that pericardial biopsy is more commonly done thoracoscopically or surgically, usually during a pericardial drainage. For a patient with an effusion of unknown cause, that matters as much as the drainage.

Pericardial Window vs Surgical Drainage

Surgical drainage is the broader term. It covers any operation that empties the pericardium, including a subxiphoid pericardiotomy with a drain, a window into the pleura, and a thoracotomy or sternotomy done to find and repair a bleeding heart or aorta. A pericardial window is the version that removes pericardium to keep an effusion from reaccumulating.

The difference matters most in an emergency. A window treats fluid. It doesn’t treat a hole in the ventricle or a dissected aorta, so “the patient needs surgical drainage” and “the patient needs a window” can describe two different operations.

How a Pericardial Window Works

How a window keeps fluid away probably depends on the approach. A pleuro-pericardial window lets fluid pass into the left pleural space, where it can be absorbed. The subxiphoid operation doesn’t create a true pleural window, and the best-known explanation for why it still works comes from one small study.

Sugimoto and colleagues’ 1990 study followed 28 patients after subxiphoid drainage, with the tube kept in until output was minimal. Twenty-six had permanent relief. Postoperative echocardiograms showed the pericardial space obliterated, and autopsies in four patients confirmed that the epicardium and pericardium had fused. The authors concluded that, in their patients, success came from that fusion and not from an opening that stayed patent.

That finding describes subxiphoid drainage in 28 patients. It shouldn’t be read as the mechanism for every approach.

When Is a Pericardial Window Indicated?

The drainage approach depends on the cause of tamponade, the patient’s condition, and available expertise. The 2025 ESC guideline indicates echocardiography- or fluoroscopy-guided pericardiocentesis for cardiac tamponade, and it separates the situations that call for surgical drainage from the narrower indication for a window:

  • Surgical drainage is required when percutaneous pericardiocentesis isn’t feasible or the effusion is purulent. Purulent effusions are often heavily loculated and reaccumulate fast, and subxiphoid pericardiotomy with rinsing of the pericardial cavity should be considered.
  • A pericardial window is indicated for a relapsing effusion with hemodynamic compromise despite conservative treatment or percutaneous drainage.
  • In neoplastic pericardial disease, pericardiotomy and a pericardial window are additional options for recurrent effusions.

A third group needs more than drainage. An ESC Council for Cardiology Practice review of pericardiocentesis lists aortic dissection and post-infarction free wall rupture as contraindications to needle pericardiocentesis, because the problem is the bleeding source. If surgery isn’t immediately available, it describes draining very small amounts only as a bridge to the operating room. Most traumatic tamponade belongs in this group too, and our pericardiocentesis guide covers how to temporize while surgery gets ready.

Which Operation Fits Which Problem

SituationWhat surgery usually meansWhySource
Purulent effusionSurgical drainage, often subxiphoid with rinsingHeavily loculated and reaccumulates quickly; complete removal neededESC 2025
Percutaneous drainage not feasibleSurgical drainageA needle can’t safely reach the fluidESC 2025
Relapsing effusion with hemodynamic compromisePericardial windowFormal indication for a windowESC 2025
Recurrent malignant effusionPericardiotomy or windowListed as additional optionsESC 2025
Aortic dissection or post-infarction free wall ruptureEmergency surgery to repair the sourceNeedle drainage is contraindicated except as a small-volume bridgeDe Carlini 2017
Penetrating trauma with tamponadeOperative exploration; a window alone only in selected stable patientsNeedle is usually temporizing; drainage alone was studied only without active bleedingStatPearls 2025; Nicol 2014

Pericardial Window in Trauma

In trauma, the window is mainly a diagnostic test, and in a narrow group of patients it can also be the treatment. It is not definitive care for every penetrating cardiac injury. An unstable patient with a stab wound and tamponade needs the bleeding found and repaired.

StatPearls’ pericardiocentesis chapter describes needle drainage in trauma as usually a temporizing measure at the bedside, with definitive treatment by pericardial window or thoracotomy with surgical pericardiotomy.

The Window as a Diagnostic Test

Studies of occult cardiac injury use the subxiphoid window as the reference standard. A 2017 Harborview study of blunt trauma states that the window “remains the gold standard” for diagnosing clinically significant hemopericardium, while noting its risks and resource use. A 2022 review of pericardial window in trauma found sensitivity of 92–100% and specificity of 96–100% for suspected penetrating cardiac injury in stable patients.

Bedside ultrasound has a known blind spot. A 2021 meta-analysis of chest ultrasound pooled five studies and 556 stable patients with penetrating thoracic trauma. Compared with a window, ultrasound was 79% sensitive and 92% specific for occult cardiac injury. False negatives clustered in patients with a concomitant left hemothorax, and the authors advise a second diagnostic test in those patients.

Drainage Alone: Only for Stable Patients Without Active Bleeding

One randomized trial supports drainage without sternotomy, and its entry criteria are the point. Nicol’s 2014 trial in Cape Town enrolled 111 patients with penetrating chest trauma who were hemodynamically stable and whose hemopericardium was confirmed at subxiphoid window with no active bleeding. They were randomized to sternotomy (55) or pericardial drainage and washout alone (56).

Of the 55 sternotomies, 51 (93%) found either no cardiac injury or a tangential one, and the four endocardial wounds had all sealed. The one death was in the sternotomy group, and ICU stay was shorter after drainage (0.25 vs 2.04 days).

This was a single trauma center. The result applies to stable patients with no active bleeding seen at the window, and it says nothing about the unstable patient or the one who is still bleeding.

Surgical Approaches: Subxiphoid, Thoracotomy and VATS

There are three main routes, and the authors of the largest recent series recommend choosing by the patient’s condition. The subxiphoid approach goes in from below the sternum. A left anterior mini-thoracotomy or video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) opens the pericardium into the left pleural space.

A 2016 comparison of subxiphoid and thoracotomy windows looked at 179 patients with a mean age of 73. Patients after a subxiphoid window were extubated sooner and used less morphine. Moderate or large recurrent effusion was more common after subxiphoid surgery (9.4% vs 0%), while perioperative death and length of stay were similar.

The same paper offers a reason. The subxiphoid route doesn’t create a true pleural window, and the opening can be blocked by bowel, liver or omentum.

VATS needs single-lung ventilation and lateral positioning, which Langdon and colleagues note may cause hemodynamic instability. In a 2024 series of 166 cancer patients, surgeons chose mini-thoracotomy when oxygenation or blood pressure made one-lung ventilation difficult, and found the two approaches comparable for preventing recurrence.

ApproachWhere the fluid goesAdvantages reportedDrawbacks reportedSource
SubxiphoidOut through a pericardial drain; no true pleural windowFaster extubation, less opioid; can be done under local anesthesia with sedationHigher recurrence in one series (9.4% vs 0%); exposure limited by obesityLangdon 2016; Gwan-Nulla 2019
Left anterior mini-thoracotomyLeft pleural spaceNo recurrence in Langdon’s series; may drain faster if the patient drops pressure on inductionLonger ventilation, more opioidLangdon 2016
VATSLeft pleural spaceSimilar recurrence to mini-thoracotomyNeeds one-lung ventilation and lateral positioningKim 2024; Langdon 2016
Peritoneal windowPeritoneal cavityOption in selected casesNot compared in these studiesESC 2025

What Happens in the OR and What to Hand Off

This is the surgeon’s operation, so what follows is for understanding the handoff. In Gwan-Nulla’s published subxiphoid technique on CTSNet (2019), the surgeon reviews the echocardiogram or CT, makes a small upper midline incision over the xiphoid, opens and excises a piece of pericardium, suctions the sac and leaves a drain. It can be done under general anesthesia or under local anesthesia with sedation, depending on how stable the patient is.

Induction Can Be the Most Dangerous Moment

A patient in tamponade can collapse before the incision. Gwan-Nulla advises that if an unstable patient needs general anesthesia, the team should prep and drape before induction, ready to operate at once. Langdon and colleagues add that a thoracotomy may drain the pericardium faster if hypotension develops on induction.

Collapse After Drainage

Patients can also deteriorate after the fluid is out, and it shouldn’t be assumed that this is low preload that fluids will fix. Pericardial decompression syndrome is a rare, potentially life-threatening complication that follows an otherwise successful drainage, by needle or by surgery. The ESC Council review describes presentations ranging from pulmonary edema to cardiogenic shock and says the mechanism isn’t well understood.

The 2025 ESC guideline advises against draining a large volume at once (usually less than 500 mL initially) to help prevent it. A patient who gets worse after drainage needs immediate reassessment, because the differential also includes reaccumulation, bleeding and the underlying disease.

What Matters in the Handoff

  • The suspected cause. Trauma, a possible dissection, a recent myocardial infarction, infection or known cancer changes which operation the surgeon plans.
  • How unstable the patient is. If the patient is already hypotensive, say so before anyone plans induction.
  • What has already been drained. Report whether a needle or catheter is in, how much came out and what it looked like.
  • Imaging. Share where the fluid sits and whether it looks loculated.
  • Anticoagulation and coagulopathy.

If the patient deteriorates before the OR is ready, needle pericardiocentesis is the usual bridge, with the exceptions above: in dissection and free wall rupture it is limited to small volumes while surgery mobilizes, and in trauma it is temporizing.

Pericardial Window vs Pericardiocentesis

A pericardial window is a surgical drainage that removes pericardium, while pericardiocentesis drains the effusion through a needle and usually a catheter. In the comparison studies, the window has lower recurrence, and mortality is similar or higher. All of the data are retrospective, so patients weren’t randomized, and the two groups differ in ways that matching can’t fully fix.

StudyPatientsRecurrenceMortalityOther findings
Horr 2017 (Cleveland Clinic, all causes)1,28124% pericardiocentesis vs 10% windowIn-hospital 5.3% vs 4.4% (p=0.49)Instability after procedure more common after window (matched 6.1% vs 2.0%)
Lee 2024 (malignant effusion)76518.0% pericardiocentesis vs 6.3% windowNo difference in all-cause deathWindow HR 0.31 for recurrence
Nahle 2026 (meta-analysis, malignant effusion)1,369 in 6 studiesProcedure failure higher with pericardiocentesis (OR 2.99)More deaths reported with windowNo difference in bleeding, infection, pneumothorax or SVT

Taken together, in these cohorts a window traded more post-procedure instability for fewer recurrences. Expect the surgical team to offer one when the fluid keeps coming back, which is the indication the ESC guideline names.

Complications and Recurrence

Most of the risk data come from older patients or patients with advanced cancer, so the numbers reflect the cohort as much as the operation. In the 2016 subxiphoid-versus-thoracotomy series (mean age 73), perioperative death was 7.1% and 7.7%. In the 2024 cancer series, there were no procedure-related deaths, and 9.6% of patients needed re-intervention for recurrence.

Older comparisons summarized by Langdon and colleagues pull in different directions on respiratory complications, mortality and recurrence between the subxiphoid and transthoracic routes. No approach has been shown to be clearly safer.

Keeping the Bedside Half of the Skill

The window belongs to the surgeon, and SimKit doesn’t teach it. What belongs to you is recognizing tamponade and getting a needle into the pericardium when that is the right bridge and the OR is too far away. Pericardiocentesis is a high-acuity, low-occurrence (HALO) procedure, and rare procedures decay without practice, a theme covered in our podcast episode on procedural skill decay.

Pericardiocentesis, not the surgical window, is one of the four procedures in SimKit’s Year 2 course. Each monthly session takes about 30 minutes, and each procedure comes back three times a year with added fidelity, which is how the spaced-repetition schedule works. Practice like this supports retention and confidence. It doesn’t replace supervised experience or institutional credentialing, and the evidence linking simulation to patient outcomes is still limited, as discussed in the episode on simulation and patient outcomes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a pericardial window open heart surgery?

The subxiphoid approach uses a small upper midline incision over the xiphoid instead of a sternotomy, and it can be done under local anesthesia with sedation (Gwan-Nulla 2019). Other approaches use a small left thoracotomy or thoracoscopy (ESC 2025).

Is a pericardial window permanent?

The goal is lasting relief, and how that happens may differ by approach. A pleuro-pericardial window drains into the pleural space. After subxiphoid drainage, one small study of 28 patients found that relief came from the epicardium fusing to the pericardium, not from an opening that stayed patent (Sugimoto 1990). Effusions can still recur after any approach.

Where does the fluid go after a pericardial window?

With a pleuro-pericardial window it drains into the left pleural space, and in selected cases into the peritoneal cavity (ESC 2025). After a subxiphoid operation, which doesn’t create a true pleural window, a drain removes the fluid until output is minimal (Langdon 2016; Sugimoto 1990).

Is a pericardial window the same as surgical drainage?

No. Surgical drainage is the broader term for any operation that empties the pericardium. A window is the version that removes pericardium to prevent reaccumulation. Tamponade from trauma, aortic dissection or free wall rupture may need surgery that repairs the bleeding source.

How long does a pericardial window take?

In a 2024 series of 166 cancer patients, mean operative time was 54.8 and 59.2 minutes for mini-thoracotomy and VATS. Subxiphoid times weren’t reported in the studies cited here.

How long is the hospital stay after a pericardial window?

Mean stays were about 11 days in a 2016 series with a mean age of 73 (Langdon 2016), and 10.5–12.9 days in a 2024 cancer series (Kim 2024). Both cohorts were older patients or patients with cancer.

What is the success rate of a pericardial window?

Reaccumulation after a window was 10% in the Cleveland Clinic comparison (Horr 2017) and 6.3% in a 2024 study of malignant effusions (Lee 2024).

Conclusion

A pericardial window is the surgeon’s answer to an effusion that keeps coming back, and in retrospective data it is associated with lower recurrence than pericardiocentesis. It is not the answer to every surgical tamponade. Purulent effusions and fluid a needle can’t reach need surgical drainage, and tamponade from trauma, aortic dissection or free wall rupture may need the bleeding source repaired.

For the emergency clinician, the work is upstream. The drainage approach depends on the cause of tamponade, the patient’s condition, and available expertise, so identify the cause early, involve surgery early when it points to one of those exceptions, and hand off clearly before induction.

SimKit teaches pericardiocentesis, not the surgical window. To keep that bedside skill sharp, see Year 2 of the Procedural Training Course.

References

  1. Schulz-Menger J, Collini V, Gröschel J, et al; ESC Scientific Document Group. 2025 ESC Guidelines for the management of myocarditis and pericarditis. Eur Heart J. 2025;46(40):3952-4041. doi:10.1093/eurheartj/ehaf192
  2. Sugimoto JT, Little AG, Ferguson MK, et al. Pericardial window: mechanisms of efficacy. Ann Thorac Surg. 1990;50(3):442-445. doi:10.1016/0003-4975(90)90491-n. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2205162/
  3. De Carlini CC, Maggiolini S. Pericardiocentesis in cardiac tamponade: indications and practical aspects. E-Journal of Cardiology Practice. 2017;15(19). https://www.escardio.org/communities/councils/cardiology-practice/scientific-documents-and-publications/ejournal/volume-15/Pericardiocentesis-in-cardiac-tamponade-indications-and-practical-aspects
  4. Willner DA, Shams P, Grossman SA. Pericardiocentesis. In: StatPearls. StatPearls Publishing; updated January 19, 2025. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK470347/
  5. Witt CE, Linnau KF, Maier RV, et al. Management of pericardial fluid in blunt trauma: variability in practice and predictors of operative outcome in patients with computed tomography evidence of pericardial fluid. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2017;82(4):733-741. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000001386. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28129264/
  6. Selvakumar S, Newsome K, Nguyen T, et al. The role of pericardial window techniques in the management of penetrating cardiac injuries in the hemodynamically stable patient: where does it fit in the current trauma algorithm? J Surg Res. 2022;276:120-135. doi:10.1016/j.jss.2022.02.018. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35339780/
  7. Manzano-Nunez R, Gomez A, Espitia D, et al. A meta-analysis of the diagnostic accuracy of chest ultrasound for the diagnosis of occult penetrating cardiac injuries in hemodynamically stable patients with penetrating thoracic trauma. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2021;90(2):388-395. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000003006. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33502150/
  8. Nicol AJ, Navsaria PH, Hommes M, Ball CG, Edu S, Kahn D. Sternotomy or drainage for a hemopericardium after penetrating trauma: a randomized controlled trial. Ann Surg. 2014;259(3):438-442. doi:10.1097/SLA.0b013e31829069a1. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23604058/
  9. Langdon SE, Seery K, Kulik A. Contemporary outcomes after pericardial window surgery: impact of operative technique. J Cardiothorac Surg. 2016;11:73. doi:10.1186/s13019-016-0466-3
  10. Kim SM, Lee JH, Chung SR, Sung K, Kim WS, Cho YH. Pericardial window operation in oncology patients: analysis of long-term survival and prognostic factors. J Chest Surg. 2024;57(2):169-177. doi:10.5090/jcs.23.113. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38228497/
  11. Gwan-Nulla D. Subxiphoid pericardial window: steps and helpful tips. CTSNet. February 5, 2019. https://www.ctsnet.org/article-video/subxiphoid-pericardial-window-steps-and-helpful-tips/
  12. Horr SE, Mentias A, Houghtaling PL, et al. Comparison of outcomes of pericardiocentesis versus surgical pericardial window in patients requiring drainage of pericardial effusions. Am J Cardiol. 2017;120(5):883-890. doi:10.1016/j.amjcard.2017.06.003. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28739031/
  13. Lee J, Kim K, Gwak SY, et al. Pericardiocentesis versus window formation in malignant pericardial effusion: trends and outcomes. Heart. 2024;110(12):863-871. doi:10.1136/heartjnl-2023-323542. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38302262/
  14. Nahle T, Bhave A, Abou Zeid K, et al. Pericardiocentesis vs. surgical pericardial window for first occurrence of malignancy-related pericardial effusion: a meta-analysis of retrospective studies. Eur Heart J Open. 2026;6(2):oeag018. doi:10.1093/ehjopen/oeag018. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41822005/

Need help? We're here to assist you!

Join Our Newsletter

* indicates required