Skip to main content

Emergency Medicine Training

← Back to blog

Medical Simulation Equipment: Types, Fidelity and How to Choose for Your Program

Jason Hine 13 min read

Quick Answer

Medical simulation equipment is any device, model or system used to recreate a clinical task or patient for training. The main categories are task trainers, full-body manikins, standardized patients, virtual reality and screen-based simulators, plus the recording and consumable supplies that keep a program running. Choose equipment by learning objective rather than by realism. A 2012 review of 24 studies found little consistent evidence that higher-fidelity simulation produced better learning outcomes than lower-fidelity approaches, while repeated and spaced practice have measurable effects on skill outcomes.

What Counts as Medical Simulation Equipment?

The Healthcare Simulation Dictionary, published by AHRQ with the Society for Simulation in Healthcare (3rd edition, 2025), defines a simulator as “a setting, device, computer program or system that performs simulation.” That range runs from a single-procedure model on a tabletop to a wireless manikin with modeled physiology.

Equipment is a wider category than simulators. A working program also needs the gear around them: cameras and debriefing software, monitors, consumables, storage and a room to run scenarios in. Those items are where many recurring costs sit.

Two terms are worth separating before you shop. Modality is the type of simulation (task trainer, manikin, standardized patient, VR). Fidelity is how closely the experience replicates the real event, and the dictionary notes that fidelity isn’t tied to any one modality. A plastic neck can be the right level of fidelity for one objective and too little for another.

Types of Medical Simulators

Most medical simulators fall into a handful of modalities. The table below uses the Healthcare Simulation Dictionary’s definitions and pairs each with the kind of objective it suits.

TypeWhat it isBest matched to
Task trainerA model of a body part or region built to train the key elements of one procedure or skillProcedural steps: landmarks, instrument handling, sequence
ManikinA life-size, human-like simulator that represents a patientResuscitation scenarios and team performance
Standardized patientA person trained to portray a patient in a realistic, repeatable wayCommunication, history-taking and physical exam
Hybrid simulationA part-task trainer attached to a standardized patientA procedure that also needs patient interaction
Virtual realityA computer-generated 3D environment the learner interacts withDecision-making in scenarios that are hard to stage physically

Task Trainers

A task trainer (also called a part-task trainer) is a device built to train the key elements of a single procedure or skill. The dictionary’s own example is lumbar puncture. Most represent one region of the body, such as an arm or an abdomen, and some add mechanical or electronic feedback.

Task trainers are the natural fit for procedural skills because the learner can repeat the same steps many times. Most low-fidelity models need no one to control or program them, which the dictionary uses as its definition of low fidelity. That makes them practical for short, frequent sessions.

Manikins (Full-Body Patient Simulators)

A manikin is a life-size, human-like simulator that represents a patient. Advanced models add breathing, pulses, voice and physiology that responds to interventions. They suit scenarios where the objective is managing the whole patient or the whole team, such as a cardiac arrest or a trauma activation.

They are also expensive. Norman and colleagues noted in 2012 that high-fidelity simulators can cost close to six figures. Unlike low-fidelity models, they generally need someone to control or program them during a scenario.

Standardized Patients and Hybrid Simulation

A standardized patient is a person trained to portray a patient with a specific condition in a consistent, repeatable way. Standardized patients are the usual choice when the objective is communication or examination.

Hybrid simulation combines modalities. The most common form attaches a part-task trainer to a standardized patient, so the learner performs a procedure while also talking to and reassuring a “patient.”

Virtual Reality and Screen-Based Simulation

Virtual reality places the learner in a computer-generated 3D environment they can interact with. Screen-based simulation runs on an ordinary monitor. Both let a program present many different cases without restaging a room.

Cost comparisons are starting to appear. A 2026 review of trauma simulation modalities (Othman et al., 21 studies) reported that VR was 40% cheaper than mannequin-based simulation, with per-participant costs of $149 versus $296. Those figures come from trauma-care training, so check whether they hold for your own objectives before you budget around them.

Audiovisual, Debriefing and Consumable Supplies

The supporting equipment rarely appears in vendor comparisons, but it shapes the running cost of a program. Recording and debriefing systems, replacement skins and tubing, cleaning supplies and storage all recur after the first year. Software licenses and service contracts can recur too.

Ask for these costs in writing before you compare simulators on purchase price alone.

High-Fidelity vs Low-Fidelity Simulation: What the Evidence Shows

High-fidelity simulation aims for extreme realism and a high level of interactivity. Low-fidelity simulation, by the dictionary’s definition, doesn’t need external control or programming for the learner to take part. High-fidelity setups often rely on expensive technology, but fidelity isn’t the same thing as sophistication: it describes how closely the experience matches the real event for a given learning objective. So the question that matters is whether added realism produces better learning for the skill you’re teaching.

A widely cited answer is a review of high- versus low-fidelity simulation by Norman, Dore and Grierson (Medical Education, 2012). They identified 24 studies that compared the two directly, in auscultation, surgical technique and complex management such as cardiac resuscitation. Both approaches improved performance over no training. Most studies found no significant advantage for high fidelity, and where differences appeared they averaged roughly 1–2%. The authors note it was a narrative review rather than a systematic one.

Simulation design standards take the same line. The INACSL Healthcare Simulation Standards of Best Practice (2021) state that “high-technology does not necessarily equate to high-fidelity.” They also say that not every simulation needs the highest level of realism, and that the right level depends on the learner, the objectives, the time and the resources available.

SimKit’s founder, Jason Hine, MD, reached a similar view in our podcast episode on simulation and patient outcomes. He describes the goal as “earned confidence,” built through deliberate practice and repetition.

How to Choose Medical Simulation Equipment

Start from what your learners need to be able to do, then pick the equipment. The INACSL Simulation Design standard (2021) makes matching the modality to the objectives one of its core design criteria.

The steps below follow that standard and add the practical questions it leaves to each program.

Start With a Needs Assessment and Measurable Objectives

The INACSL standard asks programs to begin with a needs assessment. Inputs can include stakeholder surveys, outcome data and the standards that apply to your learners. From that, write measurable objectives that build on what learners already know.

For an emergency department, a useful first pass is a list of the procedures your clinicians are expected to perform but rarely do. That list usually points straight at task trainers.

Match Modality and Fidelity to the Skill

If the objective is a sequence of hands-on steps (placing a chest tube, finding the cricothyroid membrane), a task trainer gives learners the most direct repetitions of those steps. If the objective is how a team communicates and leads during a resuscitation, a manikin run in your own department is the better match. Communication and examination objectives point to a standardized patient.

Many programs need more than one modality. The point is to buy each one for a named objective rather than buying the most realistic option and fitting objectives to it afterward.

Budget for Practice Frequency, Not Just the Purchase

Simulation training beats no training. A 2011 JAMA meta-analysis of 609 studies and 35,226 trainees found large effects on knowledge and skills compared with no training. The more useful question for a buyer is which design features make it work.

A meta-analysis of simulation design features (Cook et al., 2013; 289 studies) reported pooled skill effect sizes of 0.68 for practice across a range of difficulty and 0.66 for distributed practice. Repetitive practice also scored 0.68, though in only seven studies and short of statistical significance.

Spacing has trial evidence behind it as well. In a randomized trial of massed versus distributed practice (Moulton et al., Annals of Surgery, 2006), 38 junior surgical residents learned microvascular anastomosis with the same total practice time. Residents who trained in weekly sessions outperformed those trained in a single day on both retention and transfer.

For equipment decisions, this means counting how many times each clinician will get hands on a device across a year. A portable model that clinicians can access between shifts may create more opportunities for repeated practice than equipment available only during scheduled simulation sessions.

Decide Where Practice Will Happen

Equipment choices change with location. A dedicated simulation center suits scheduled, instructor-led sessions. In situ simulation, which the dictionary defines as simulation on a patient care unit with team members in their own work environment, tests your real equipment, space and workflows.

Short, frequent procedural practice often happens somewhere else entirely: in a break room or at home. That only works if the equipment is portable and needs no operator.

Questions to Ask Before You Buy

  • Which objectives from your needs assessment does this equipment serve?
  • Does it need a trained operator or programmer, and who will that be?
  • What will consumables, replacement parts, software licenses and support cost after year one?
  • How many times a year will each clinician realistically use it?
  • Can it be used where your team works, or only in the sim center?
  • Does it work with the devices your department actually stocks?

Simulation Equipment for Rare Emergency Procedures

Emergency medicine has a specific equipment problem: high-acuity, low-occurrence (HALO) procedures. These are the interventions that matter most when they’re needed and come up too rarely to stay sharp on through clinical work alone.

Surgical airway is the standard example. In the National Emergency Airway Registry (Offenbacher et al., 2023), 49 of 17,720 patients who had at least one intubation attempt went on to a rescue surgical airway attempt. That is 2.8 per 1,000. We walk through those numbers in our podcast episode on surgical airway incidence.

Skills learned in simulation also fade. A systematic review of procedural skill retention (Legoux et al., AEM Education and Training, 2021) pooled 10 studies with 317 participants, covering intubation, cricothyrotomy and central line insertion. Mean scores fell from their immediate post-training level by 3 months in 4 of 4 studies that measured it, by 6 months in 3 of 4, and at 12 months or later in 2 of 5. Scores mostly stayed above the pre-training baseline. The authors rated the evidence as low to moderate quality.

Put together, those findings shape what a department should buy for HALO procedures. A single annual course on an expensive simulator leaves long gaps between repetitions. Equipment that supports short sessions spaced through the year fits the evidence better. Between hands-on sessions, mental rehearsal can help, which we cover in our episode on mental practice for rare procedures.

How SimKit Fits a Department Program

SimKit is built around low-fidelity procedural task trainers paired with an online curriculum. Each session takes about 30 minutes: read the steps and indications, watch the procedure, practice on the model, then complete a short reflective quiz. You can see how the monthly kits work on our site.

The physician course covers cricothyrotomy, lateral canthotomy, gastroesophageal balloon tamponade and tube thoracostomy in Year 1, then central venous catheterization, pericardiocentesis, transvenous pacing and cranial burr hole in Year 2. Each procedure comes back every three months, and the models start simple and add tactile fidelity across the year. The EMS track covers IO access, jet ventilation, Seldinger and surgical cricothyrotomy, needle decompression and chest tube insertion (which of these a provider may perform depends on state protocols and medical direction). Clinicians keep the models.

Device-specific items such as balloon tamponade tubes and central line kits aren’t included. As the SimKit FAQ on included equipment explains, that’s so your team practices on the devices your department actually stocks.

For departments, a leader dashboard lets you create teams, invite members and track participation and completion. Custom packages can share models between clinicians while each person keeps individual access to the curriculum. The kits also work alongside an existing in situ program.

SimKit practice supports skill retention and confidence between real cases. It doesn’t certify competence or replace credentialing and supervised clinical experience. If you run in situ simulation already, see adding kits to an in situ sim program.

FAQ

What equipment do you need to start a medical simulation program?

Start with a needs assessment and a list of measurable objectives, then buy the modality that matches each one. For most procedural objectives that means task trainers first, with manikins added for team-based scenarios.

Is high-fidelity simulation better than low-fidelity?

Not consistently, for the skills studied so far. A 2012 review of 24 direct comparisons found little consistent evidence that high-fidelity simulation produced better learning outcomes, with average differences of about 1–2%. The right level of fidelity depends on the learning objective.

What is a task trainer?

A task trainer is a model, usually of one body part or region, built to train the key elements of a single procedure or skill. Lumbar puncture, IV access and cricothyrotomy models are common examples.

What is the difference between a manikin and a simulator?

A simulator is any device, setting, program or system that performs simulation. A manikin is one type of simulator: a life-size, human-like model that represents a patient.

Does simulation training improve patient outcomes?

The evidence is strongest for learner skills, confidence and team performance. A 2026 review of 21 trauma-simulation studies reported faster team processes, but evidence that simulation lowers patient mortality is still limited.

How often should clinicians practice rare procedures?

No standard interval exists, but a 2021 systematic review found skill scores falling within 3 months of training in all four studies that assessed retention at three months. Trials favor spacing practice across multiple sessions over a single long one.

Conclusion

The right medical simulation equipment is whatever meets your objectives and gets used often. The fidelity evidence doesn’t justify paying for realism your objectives don’t need, and the practice evidence favors equipment your clinicians can reach repeatedly across the year. For rare emergency procedures, that usually means accessible task trainers on a spaced schedule, with manikins and in situ scenarios kept for the team skills they suit best.

If you’re building a program like that for your department, see team training for emergency departments.

References

  1. Lioce L, Lopreiato J, Anderson M, et al, eds; Terminology and Concepts Working Group. Healthcare Simulation Dictionary. 3rd ed. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality; 2025. AHRQ Publication No. 24-0077. https://www.ahrq.gov/patient-safety/resources/simulation/terms.html
  2. INACSL Standards Committee, Watts PI, McDermott DS, Alinier G, Charnetski M, Nawathe PA. Healthcare Simulation Standards of Best Practice: Simulation Design. Clin Simul Nurs. 2021;58:14-21. doi:10.1016/j.ecns.2021.08.009
  3. Norman G, Dore K, Grierson L. The minimal relationship between simulation fidelity and transfer of learning. Med Educ. 2012;46(7):636-647. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2012.04243.x
  4. Cook DA, Hatala R, Brydges R, et al. Technology-enhanced simulation for health professions education: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA. 2011;306(9):978-988. doi:10.1001/jama.2011.1234. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21900138/
  5. Cook DA, Hamstra SJ, Brydges R, et al. Comparative effectiveness of instructional design features in simulation-based education: systematic review and meta-analysis. Med Teach. 2013;35(1):e867-e898. doi:10.3109/0142159X.2012.714886. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22938677/
  6. Moulton CA, Dubrowski A, MacRae H, Graham B, Grober E, Reznick R. Teaching surgical skills: what kind of practice makes perfect? A randomized, controlled trial. Ann Surg. 2006;244(3):400-409. doi:10.1097/01.sla.0000234808.85789.6a. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16926566/
  7. Legoux C, Gerein R, Boutis K, Barrowman N, Plint A. Retention of critical procedural skills after simulation training: a systematic review. AEM Educ Train. 2021;5(3):e10536. doi:10.1002/aet2.10536. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34099989/
  8. Offenbacher J, Nikolla DA, Carlson JN, et al. Incidence of rescue surgical airways after attempted orotracheal intubation in the emergency department: a National Emergency Airway Registry (NEAR) study. Am J Emerg Med. 2023;68:22-27. doi:10.1016/j.ajem.2023.02.020. PubMed: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36905882/
  9. Othman Y, Kata A, Jayagopi K, et al. A concise review investigating simulation modalities’ effects on team efficiency, provider wellbeing, education & clinical outcomes. Am J Emerg Med. 2026;102:27-33. doi:10.1016/j.ajem.2026.01.002

Need help? We're here to assist you!

Join Our Newsletter

* indicates required